| Year |
Captains |
| 1956 |
Bill Fardy |
| 1957 |
Doug Davidson & Even Wiechman |
| 1958 |
Dick Hart & Dick Ruge |
| 1959 |
Roger Kerkman & Dave Spies |
| 1960 |
Roger Johnson & Keene Warren |
| 1961 |
Marv Paitrick & Les Nesbit |
| 1962 |
Larry Davis & Larry Gocker |
| 1963 |
Don Sydow & Frank Parish |
| 1964 |
John Martinek & Ron Bronson |
| 1965 |
Jerry Schmidt & Leo Kelly |
| 1966 |
Bob Berezowitz & Ross Gordon |
| 1967 |
Barry Wojtak & Bill Banonse |
| 1968 |
Al Equi & Neil Hansen |
| 1969 |
Bruce Rasmussen & Larry Dickerson |
| 1970 |
Lon Kolstad & Tom Konowalski |
| 1971 |
Mike Dressler & Mike Yankunas |
| 1972 |
Toby Ackerman & Al Thies |
| 1973 |
Jim Walters & Bill Roper |
| 1974 |
Kerry Larsen & Bill Simons |
| 1975 |
Bill Barwick & Steve Gerber |
| 1976 |
John Koebler & Rick Lagerman |
| 1977 |
Ed Hanner & Scott Viesselmann |
| 1978 |
Scott Gerth & Jim Vogel |
| 1979 |
Mike LaLoggia & Tom Stuebe |
| 1980 |
Tony Azarian & Jim Haluska |
| 1981 |
Jay Clark & Mike Meyers |
| 1982 |
Joe Gerlach, Jon Miller, Al Alder & Tom Patterson |
| 1983 |
Curt Chybowski & Dan Turelli |
| 1984 |
Pete Aisbet & Randy Kress |
| 1985 |
Jon Giese & Brent Engen |
| 1986 |
Tom Spaltholz & Steve Chumra |
| 1987 |
Chris Waldoch, Mike Schroeder & Mike Johanning |
| 1988 |
John Speigelhoff, Dave Haluska & Jim Jaworski |
| 1989 |
Jim Sherman, Dick Schuh & John Sterner |
| 1990 |
Pat Crowley, Shawn Eichorst & Bryan Tarrolly |
| 1991 |
Dennis Bogacz, Kyle Dempsey, Rod Donart & Brian Kuhnau |
| 1992 |
Mike Bell, Brian Hooper, Jeff Patterson & Todd Peterson |
| 1993 |
Talmadge Kimmons, Tim DeForest, Nick Roelli & Dave Lang |
| 1994 |
Chad Chellevold, Paul Luling & Brett Sascheider |
| 1995 |
Scott Hawig, Eric Melka & JJ Webb |
| 1996 |
Sean Stout, Derrick LeVake, Craig Havertape & Chad Pearson |
| 1997 |
Derrick LeVake, John DaMato, Marty Vosburg & RJ Safranek |
| 1998 |
Ty Grovesteen, Art Gutierrez, Andy Weber, Jason Bartolotta & Dave Vitel |
| 1999 |
Brad Kligora, Jeremy Doering, Dan Johnson, Jeff McKenzie & Tywone Redmond |
| 2000 |
Jake Wolter, Paul Strobusch, Pete Engstrom & Chris Korff |
| 2001 |
Steve Tenhagen & Pete Katz |
| 2002 |
Dan Flanagan & Randy Borgardt |
| 2003 |
Tom Karthhauer & Chad Wurt |
| 2004 |
Andy Walters & Dustin Hausherr |
| 2005 |
Colin Price & Jim Leszczynski |
| 2006 |
Ryan Kleppe & Justin Jacobs |
| 2007 |
Justin Beaver & Ryan Ogrizovich |
| 2008 |
Nick Slupski & Jace Rindahl |
| 2009 |
Garth Coats, Jeff Donovan, Troney Shumpert & Paul Wick |
| 2010 |
Jon Baldwin, Mark Gawronski, Lane Olson & Aaron Rusch |
| 2011 |
Greg Arnold & Matt Blanchard |
| 2012 |
Jake Hohlstein & Lee Brekke |
| 2013 |
Tyler Huber, Cole Klotz & Matt Behrendt |
| 2014 |
Matt Behrendt, Jake Kumerow & Marcus McLin |
| 2015 |
Zach Franz, Conner Peters, Ryan Winske & Joe Worth |
| 2016 |
Paul Foster, Austin Jones & John Flood |
| 2017 |
Bryce Leszczynski, Jordan Mueller, Mitchell Schauer & Matt Seitz |
| 2018 |
Bryce Leszczynski, Nate Trewyn & Harry Henschler |
| 2019 |
Jacob Erbs, Quinn Meinerz, Ronny Ponick & Nate Tranel |
| 2021 |
Mackenzie Balanganayi, Kyle Gannon, Mark McGrath, Ryan Ponick & Ryan Wisniewski |
| 2022 |
Egon Hein, Tyler Holte, Evan Lewandowski & Preston Strasburg |
| 2023 |
Jason Ceniti, Hawk Heffner, Egon Hein, Drake Martin & Zach Sherman |
