Cohrs is a two-year first team All-WIAC and All-Great Lakes Region infielder for the Warhawk softball team. She has helped UW-Whitewater claim three straight WIAC regular season championships, two conference tournament titles (2017, 2018) and three consecutive appearances in the NCAA Tournament. In 2019, Cohrs batted .304 with nine doubles and 26 runs batted in, which ranked among the top 10 in the league. As a freshman in 2017, she ranked among the top 10 in the WIAC in RBIs (40), hits (53), home runs (5), total bases (75), walks (16) and batting average (.376). Cohrs is a three-time Easton/National Fastpitch Coaches Association Scholar-Athlete, three-year member of the WIAC Scholastic Honor Roll and 2019-20 UW-Whitewater Chancellor's Scholar-Athlete. She is majoring in mathematics.